Search
Tags
Options
Related Posts



animator_expo concept_art mahiro_maeda production_materials settei

Edit | Respond

Casshan
over 8 years ago
This short was pretty bad. 3d cgi sucks.
alleksi
over 8 years ago
Casshan said:
3d cgi sucks.
That's a pretty bold statement.
The 3D worked okay in this; had it not been for the movement (which the anime industry struggles with) it could have easily fooled people into thinking it was 2D in some of the cuts, but when you look at the traditionally animated sequences that happened within the cockpit, you can't help but think how much better it would have been had it been traditionally animated.

Still for example the faces worked quite well even though they were 3D
Casshan
over 8 years ago
alleksi said:
That's a pretty bold statement.
The 3D worked okay in this; had it not been for the movement (which the anime industry struggles with) it could have easily fooled people into thinking it was 2D in some of the cuts, but when you look at the traditionally animated sequences that happened within the cockpit, you can't help but think how much better it would have been had it been traditionally animated.

Still for example the faces worked quite well even though they were 3D
I think it could work much better with 2d Okiura style. The 2d animation was very poor aswell in this.