Partial Genga for:
Cut 4


Cut 14 (Hamasu?)


Cut 22 (Hamasu?)
 
Edited to remove BANK from post #237053 (which is why there's a slightly jarring cut at 0:13).

Romi in the tube at 0:11.1 is BANK from the same post, but cropped differently so we can more fully see her hair, while Cain's character acting in the cut is of course original to this scene.
 
Partial Genga
 
N4ssim said:

Source: https://w.atwiki.jp/sakuga/pages/48.html
■火の鳥 エデンの宙(Web配信/2023) 原画 ep1
ロミにつわりが訪れ口元を抑えて席を立つシーン
 
Date 12:25 User Kazuradrop Rating Safe Score 0
Woah, an equilibrium reference
 
SpencerWan said:
Outsourced to MUA Film. They did a tremendous job.
 
Date Sep 16, 2022 User WTBorp Rating Safe Score 32
 
Park's been doing this at least since Jujutsu Kaisen 0, the cuts from 0:58.4 onward in post #204770 is directly taken from Ip Man one-to-one, down to the scene composition. If anything this is downright tame by comparison lol
Honestly deleting his traced scenes is for the best in respect to the animators.
LoogiBaloogi said:
Park's been doing this at least since Jujutsu Kaisen 0, the cuts from 0:58.4 onward in post #204770 is directly taken from Ip Man one-to-one, down to the scene composition. If anything this is downright tame by comparison lol
Yea, but heavy live action reference can get away as homage (tho it definitely straddles the line sometimes) whereas this feels much more like plagiarism. It is difficult cuz obviously animators should be allowed to make references to other animation, but especially with the preexisting impact frame controversy, it’s hard to give Park the benefit of the doubt here, imo
MuddyYoshi said:
Second cut is heavily derived from Weilin's work from the Hades trailer post #129853, with some very minor timing tweaks (timing is almost identical).

0:19.8 (specifically starting at frame 502) is very heavily referenced (1:1 timing) from Naoki Kobayashi's work in post #206053 for Naruto: Shippuden ED32

you thought it couldn't get worse.
More inspired than traced it seems
https://imgur.com/a/S3VYXNs
Gibson said:
More inspired than traced it seems
https://imgur.com/a/S3VYXNs
Your gif didn’t line them up properly. I edited my comment to add comparisons
MuddyYoshi said:
Your gif didn’t line them up properly. I edited my comment to add comparisons
Looking at, you're right lol. I still wouldn't say it's traced but, maybe I'm not looking at it hard enough.
 
 
Date Apr 21 User BakaManiaHD Rating Safe Score 291
Some very underrated character acting here. I like it.
so good, i almost thought it was Ota again for a second.
The roundedness of the art makes it seem very Soty-like. Is it one of his student?
First cut looks exactly like tate style🤩